🔥💩🔥
This is The Hellscape, a weekly rant paired with praxis and community.
On November 4, the day after the election broke hard in Democrats’ favor, Hakeem Jefferies said, “The American people don’t want us to get even; they want us to get things done on their behalf.” (Bluesky)
I am going to scream into a pillow.
They took a decade of our lives. A DECADE. They shot people in the streets. They stole children from their families and sent them to prison camps and lost them. They cozied up to dictators and they protected pedophiles. They raided the fucking capitol.
I do not want “unity” with these people. I want prosecutions, impeachments, and prison sentences. I want us to cut out the rot, so we can begin to heal.
This is a conflict, and there are sides.
Here is Indivisible, on Election night:
A year ago, Senate Democrats folded in the shutdown fight and walked away with nothing for working families. Voters haven't forgotten, and neither have we. This majority is a second chance, and the grassroots who earned it expect Democrats to use every ounce of their power. (Mastodon)
My question for Democrats who want to leave the past behind is this: When Republicans hold power, do they reach across the aisle? Do they emphasize bipartisanship? Do they “go high?”
Of course they don't. They dream up shit like Project 2025 and embark on a generational project of dismantling the commons. They stack the courts with accused rapists and corrupt influence peddlers who carry water for the party. They elevate xenophobia and white supremacy. They pave over the Rose Garden and tear down the East Wing of the fucking White House.
You know who I do want unity with? The left flank of the Democratic party: the socialists and the progressives and the young people who’ve been putting up with geriatric, out-of-touch, AIPAC-funded corporate DINOs for our entire goddamn lives because these people Will. Not. Fucking. Retire.
I want unity with the people on the left who will spend the rest of their lives cleaning up this mess.
We’ve tried the Republican thing over and over and over, since before I was even born. All it’s ever gotten us is bigotry, corruption, war, and debt. What if—and I know this sounds crazy, but stay with me here—what if we just… stopped fucking doing that?
What if we stopped craving validation from the bad guys?
What if we stopped compromising with hate?
What if we stopped “reaching across the aisle” to make pacts with demons?
What if we gasp actually governed? 🤯
Marcy Wheeler has a counterargument re: Hakeem Jefferies specifically:
In my opinion, Hakeem Jeffries — who I concede many of you likely hate as a person — has been maximally effective. In the last 20 months, House Dems were repeatedly unified on votes (especially funding and the war) which, in the past, some Democrats would have voted with Republicans. Dem unity made splits in the GOP caucus really disastrous for Mike Johnson, leading to real schisms in the GOP caucus. Mike Johnson’s fecklessness didn’t just happen; Dems did everything they could to force it to happen and maximize the impact. (emptywheel)
Her core thesis is that Jefferies’ audience is the Democratic caucus, not the American people, and that when he goes on TV and says whatever he says, his words are chosen to keep the caucus unified, not to inspire progressive voters.
And, like… that’s fine insofar as insider political strategy goes, but there is broader cultural context here: we’ve spent a decade watching powerful criminals act with impunity and receive no consequences, and if you want to hold a law-abiding society together, there have to be consequences.
If you don't correct harmful behavior, it will just keep happening.
And if you let it go for long enough, eventually the rest of us will start to ask uncomfortable questions. Why do I have to follow the law? Why do I have to pay my taxes? Why do I have to respect others’ rights? Why do Republicans get to act with impunity, while Democrats must consistently fall upon our own swords?
Why should I keep trying to be a good person, when the bad people reap all the rewards?
When establishment Democrats decline to prosecute past crimes, they reinforce a version of the world in which power and wealth accrue to those who steal it, and they undermine the promise of a free and equal society.
Jefferies might intend his message for his caucus, but the public can still hear it, and it tells us something about the kind of world we live in and how we should move through it.
The process for selecting the next Speaker of the House is underway. Write to your representative and tell them what kind of leadership you want to see in this moment. You can find your representative here.
You just read issue #9 of The Hellscape. You can also browse the full archives of this newsletter.
Add a comment: